published August 15, 2026
updated October 14, 2026

Online creators should own and control the platforms they rely on

Creator platform like Patreon and Substack would work much better under cooperative ownership, giving the profits and control back to the creators who make them valuable.
project status: investigation

We're researching this project, but not currently doing any work to build it.

For many years after its 2013 launch Patreon had flat pricing, 5% of creator income earned on the platform.

Then in 2019 they changed it to a confusing tiered system, where all tiers were higher: 8%, 10%, and 12%.

In 2025, Patreon changed it once more, to eliminate the tiers and permanently raise prices to 10% for everyone (with some people grandfathered in, for now).

Substack started with the higher 10% pricing, perhaps realizing they could get away with it from the jump.

These kinds of corporate shenanigans are exactly the kind of platform decay that is practically inevitable when a platform has such strong switching costs. It's tough to move all your patrons who maybe pay your rent every month to a different system!

But what if platforms like Patreon and Substack were owned by the creators instead of shareholders?

post
The massive, but unrealized, power of cooperatives
Cooperatives governed using more adaptive and accountable systems could be much smoother and more ambitious.
Read more  →

Platforms like Patreon and Substack etc are the perfect fit to be cooperatives (businesses that are owned by their members and exist solely for their benefit). Since the creators on Patreon and Substack etc potentially make their entire living on the platform and use it on a regular basis, they have exactly the kind of regular involvement and vested interest that makes a cooperative work wonderfully.

How would this cooperative creator platform work? ​

Why would a creator choose to join a cooperative like this one? What would the benefits be? If such a thing were created by Unbreaking Lab, here's how it would work:

  • Pricing would be 5% of creator income at maximum. As the cooperative gains economies of scale, the fee would automatically reduce to proportionally share the actual cost of operations across creators. No shareholders taking a cut anymore.
  • All features would be fully available to all creators from their inception and into perpetuity. No tiers or gates.
  • The entire platform would be open source and developed in public, so members can see and contribute to the code they're relying on.
  • Any costs that aren't incurred by all creators (such as for hosting large media files or video streaming) would just be passed through directly, meaning the individual member would just pay the actual incurred cost of those activities rather than raising fees for everyone. These actual compute costs tend to be very small (truly cents per month), and don't justify fee raises for infrastructure not everyone uses.
  • And of course as mentioned above, the creators who actually use the platform would legally own it, and be able to adaptively vote to replace the board, CEO, and governing bylaws.

The last point about governance might seem boring or unimportant to you, but it's absolutely the most critical part of the model. If the creators don't own and control the platform, then the only leverage they can wield against the corporate owners is to threaten to leave. And then the switching costs I mentioned above would bite, and hard.

A cooperative is structurally different. Since you and your fellow creators literally own and control the platform, it is inherently oriented toward you and your best interests. You control who the CEO and board are, you control the legal bylaws, you control the feature prioritization, you control everything. Once the cooperative is up and running sustainably, it will always exist as long as the owners find it useful. This structural change drives the organization to get better and better over time, rather than decaying as shareholders tighten their grip.

Tell us if we should do this! ​

If you're a creator or patron on a site like Patreon or Substack we'd love to hear from you to discuss your thoughts and experiences. We want to know what matters most to users of these platforms, and therefore what the cooperative version would best look like.

Fill out the survey

Thank you! A better world is possible.