tool This is a tool page, meaning it's a technical description of a concept rather than a readable essay.
published October 13, 2026
updated October 14, 2026

Accountable Crowdfunding

This concept will be implemented as part of the Unbreaking Fund project.

project
Unbreaking Fund
A crowdfunding platform built for cooperative investment pledges and other needed mechanisms.
Read more  →

Crowdfunding is obviously a good idea, and has been proven effective.

However it's generally well-understood that a crowdfunding campaign is unlikely to be successful if the creators don't already have a large following and a strong reputation. This is a waste, and leaves lots of potentially beneficial projects undone.

The ability to "build a reputation" doesn't necessarily correlate with the ability to successfully complete an impactful project. There are many deeply skilled, creative, and determined people who don't have the opportunity (or forethought) to do their work in public. Most of the work that most people do at their day jobs is private and counts for nothing in the public square that is the internet.

And even worse, there are many people who are very skilled at building a reputation that definitely don't have the skill to complete an impactful project! It's pretty easy to put together a team of marketers and designers and hype a product that you definitely can't build.

Accountable Crowdfunding is intended to fix this problem in both directions. By distributing the money to creators only a bit at a time, and allowing backers to shut down projects that aren't making progress and refund whatever money's left, backers will feel safer taking risks on unknown creators or very large projects.

Here's the core idea of how an Accountable Crowdfunding project would unfold:

  • Creators draft a project description as usual, but they must include a detailed plan with monthly budgets, project milestones, and cushion for the unexpected.
  • Backers pledge to the project, raising the full budget amount. The project begins once the entire budget is raised.
  • For the entire project duration, only one month (or whatever period) of funds are released to the creators at a time. This means the maximum they can run away with is a single period of budget. Creators are as usual expected to give updates on their progress.
  • Every period the backers can cast a vote weighted by the size of their backing on whether the project should continue (exact details not yet determined). If at some period the backers vote not to continue the project, the remaining budget is refunded to them prorated by how much has already been spent.
  • If the project completes and the backers vote that they're satisfied and the project is complete, then whatever budget is left over is given to the creators as a "prize". This gives them an incentive to finish on time and under budget. (It might make sense to allow budgets to explicitly include an extra "prize.")

This simple "vote to continue" system would be enough to prevent (and therefore deter) the most malicious actors. But the greatest benefit is that it shifts the burden of trust from creators onto the platform itself, making it easier for backers to feel safe and so back creators who haven't built any kind of reputation.

Further it allows the creators to build the idea of "increasing reputation" into the project timeline itself! Often the early phases of a project are meant to cheaply dispel unknowns and derisk the idea, and these early exploratory phases are usually much cheaper than later phases. If unknown creators are able to design the project timeline to cheaply validate themselves and the project before ramping up cost and complexity, then their pitch will be more convincing despite their lack of reputation.

In general, if we want our world to have more shared and open public goods we need to build institutions that create trust and allow more cooperation. People with creative ideas and the skills to execute them shouldn't have to dither around tweeting or writing blog posts to build up their reputation. They should be able to bring their ideas directly to the communities most possibly interested in them, and have a reasonable chance of getting an opportunity to prove their mettle.